The GAB.

Group benefits blog

  • Home
  • About GAB
  • Group Benefits Blog
  • The Friday GAB
  • Contact

4/25/2022

Group Benefits Terminology A-Z

Read Now
 
Actively at Work - The employee is at work for the employer (not disabled or on leave). Detailed definition is included in the group contract.
AD&D - Accidental Death & Dismemberment - pays for accidental death, or for loss of limb, eyesight, etc.
Agent of Record - The Agent of Record is the advisor appointed by the plan sponsor. An AOR letter is required on the plan sponsor’s letterhead in order for the insurer to pay commission and to release information to the advisor.
ASO - Administrative Services Only - a non-insured plan where the Employer is paying for all the claims plus an administration fee for the Insurer’s claim payment services.
Assignment – When used in the context of health or dental claims, it means the employee can “assign” payment to the Insurer. This is done, for example, with a dentist so that the dentist can bill the Insurer direct and not require payment up front from the patient.
Anti-Selection – A situation where only the individuals in poor health join the plan and health individuals do not; where the option is available for employees to opt in or out; the smaller the group, the less “choice” there needs to be to avoid anti-selection.
 
Benefit or Benefit Amount - More correctly called the “volume”, this is the amount of insurance. For example, an employee insured for $50,000 of Life insurance has a benefit of $50,000 or a volume of $50,000.
 
CI - Critical Illness Insurance – pays a lump sum tax free amount to the insured on diagnosis of serious illness such as cancer, stroke, etc.
Class – When referring to employee benefits, “class” is a group of employees that have identical benefits. Example: Class A could be Executives, Class B could be Office Staff, and
Class C could be Yard Workers. Each would enjoy a different level of benefits.
COLA – Cost of Living Adjustment - usually a benefit that can be added to Long Term Disability, it allows the benefit to increase each year based on a defined formula that is usually tied to CPI (Consumer Price Index).
CPP - Canada Pension Plan (and QPP Is Quebec Pension Plan).
Conversation Privilege- Contractual right for plan members to apply to replace group coverage the lose with individual coverage without a need to submit evidence of insurability.
COB – Coordination of Benefits - This clause helps insurers determine the order of payment when both the employee and the spouse have group insurance through their employers. COB order is as follows:
  1. The individual employed
  2. The spouse plan
  3. Spending account if applicable
For a dependent child where both parents have a group insurance plan, the plan of the parent whose birthday is first in the year is the first payor.
 
Cost-Plus – is a Private Health Services Plan. This is an arrangement to provide a facility for payment of legitimate expenses as listed by the income tax act under the medical expense category.
 When used in reference to offering health or dental benefits, is a facility to have the employer pay for health or dental expense, and pay an administration fee for the privilege. Running the expense through an Insurer creates a tax-free payment to the employee. If the Employer were to reimburse the employee directly for the expense, then it would be considered “salary” and would be taxable to the employee.
Credibility - Degree of reliability that the group's own experience can predict future claims.

​DEN – Dental
Dependent - Members of the employee’s family who are eligible for benefits.
DIN - Drug Identification Number (shows on prescription receipt).
DPL - Dependent Life Insurance - nominal amounts of life insurance on an employee’s spouse and children.
 
EAP / EFAP - Employee & Family Assistance Plan - provides confidential counselling or resources to employees and usually their family members as well.
EHB - Extended Health Benefits - Coverage for health expenses incurred by the employee (and his dependents if applicable) not covered by the provincial health care plans such as semi-private hospital, prescription drugs and medical services and supplies.
EHC - Extended Health Care - means exactly the same as EHB.
EP3 Statement - Certificate issued by the insurer to confirm the drug plan is eligible for national drug industry pooling and is protected by the insurer's Extended Drug Policy Protection Plan pooling.
EP - Elimination Period (used with Long Term Disability). This refers to the waiting period an
employee must be totally disabled before LTD benefits become payable.
“Evidence of Good Health” – Refers to a medical questionnaire an employee must complete
to disclose medical history. Also referred to as “health evidence”, for example: “the employee
must supply evidence of health…”
Experience - Certificate issued by the insurer to confirm the drug plan is eligible for national drug industry pooling and is protected by the insurer's Extended Drug Policy Protection Plan pooling.
 
Generic Drugs - Generic drugs contain the same active medical ingredients as the corresponding brand name and there therefore considered therapeutic equivalents. Generic products generally cost less and if purchased instead of brand name drugs, can reduce drug plan costs.
Grandfather – In insurance terms means taking on the same level of benefits as an employee
had with a previous carrier, so that the employee does not lose benefits. This is standardly
done for Life and LTD. It is important an employee not use a valuable (and possibly
irreplaceable) benefit because the employer changed Insurers. See also the term “takeover”.
Gross or Net Rates - Net rates are the premium rates charged by the Insurer; gross rates are
the rates the TPA charges the client. The difference is the TPA’s commission and fees.
 
HSA or HCSA– Healthcare Spending Account – A healthcare spending account is a fund of money provided to employees by the employer. The employee can use these funds to pay for anything that CRA has deemed a medical expense. Employers pay an admin fee, that may or may not include commission to the HSA provider to administer the claims
 
IBNR – Incurred but not Reported - The insurer is required to set funds aside to fund claims that may be made but are not yet known to the insurer, in the event that the plan terminates. It is most often a per cent of claims.
 
LAP – Large amount pooling – pooling – stop loss - Level over which a plan member's claims are directed to a pool with other large claimants and replaced by a pooling change to reduce claims volatility.
Late Applicant - Eligible plan member who applies to join the plan after the application period (usually 31 days after becoming eligible) has expired.
LTD - Long Term Disability - A monthly insurance payment made to a disabled employee after a period of illness or injury.
 
Medical Evidence - A health statement an employee completes to show he is in good health.
The Insurer reserves the right to order other medical evidence as a result of what is disclosed
on the health statement.
MGA – Managing General Agency – an organization that does back office work for financial advisors and group benefit advisors.
 
NEL - Non-Evidence Limit – maximum amount of insurance an employee can receive without
medical evidence of good health.
NEM - Non-Evidence Maximum – exactly the same as NEL.
Net Rates or Gross Rates - net rates are the premium rates charged by the Insurer; gross
rates are the rates the TPA charges the client. The difference is the TPA’s
commission and fees
Non-Smoker – Has not used any tobacco products at all (including snuff, marijuana, Nicorette
gum) for 12 consecutive months. NOTE: Voluntary (optional) benefits may include
smoker/non-smoker rates, however basic group insurance benefits do not, and employees are
not asked if they are smokers unless applying for excess coverage or optional coverages for which they are eligible to apply.
NPC – No prior coverage - a group that has never had a group benefits program.
 
OL - Optional Life Insurance – an employee may purchase additional insurance, with medical
evidence (that is, a health questionnaire).
OM- Overall maximum – the maximum insurance an individual can apply for, even with
medical evidence.
OOC - Out-of-Country - refers to being covered for Extended Health while traveling outside
Canada.
 
Paramedical Services – Chiropractor, psychologist, massage therapist, naturopath, speech
therapist, and more (covered under Extended Health).
PDD - Pay-Direct Drug Card - use it at the pharmacy and the pharmacist can bill the insurer
direct.
Plan Member - An employee or their dependent who are covered under a group
Plan Sponsor - The Employer who holds the Group Insurance contract
Pre-Ex - Pre-Existing Condition
Pre-determination of benefits - An estimate submitted by a dentist for certain major dental expenses (such as crowns, bridges, dentures or braces) before the dental work begins.
Preferred Provider – the Insurance Companies an advisor prefers to deal with.
Provider - Insurance Company/Insurer - occasionally the insurer is called the “underwriter”.
 
R&C - Reasonable and Customary - if a benefit has an R & C limit it means the insurer doesn’t
name a limit in the contract but would not pay unlimited amounts for an expense. The
reimbursement would be limited to what the insurer considers reasonable.
Rate (or unit rate) - multiply the rate by the volume (benefit) to get the premium.
Renewal Date – The policy anniversary. Group Insurance contracts usually renew one year
after the inception date, although occasionally the first renewal will be longer (e.g. 15 months).
Once the policy has had its first renewal it will renew annually thereafter. For example, if a plan
has a renewal date of September 1, then the rates are subject to change (renew) September 1
every year.
RFP / RTP / RTQ - Request to Quote - Facts submitted to the insurer on a group prospect by a licensed adviosr in order to obtain a quotation.
 
SIC – Standard Industry Code – a list of business categories compiled by Dun & Bradstreet (in
the US) or Stats Canada (in Canada). Most Insurers use D&B. A code is assigned to each
business type. Example: 8600 would be Health; 8620 is non-hospital institutional health
services; 8663 is Practical nurses. Code 6300 is Retail; 6311 would be auto dealers, 6330 gas
stations; and so on.
STD - Short Term Disability - pays an employee an income while unable to work due to accident
or sickness. When used in the world of Group Insurance it hardly ever means “sexually
transmitted disease”.
 
Takeover – Refers to “grandfathering” of benefits as in, “we will take over your existing benefits with no loss of coverage”. Legislation requires this of all Insurers for Life and LTD. A copy of the prior Insurer’s billing statement must be sent to the new Carrier to ensure no employee loses coverage. NOTE: some Carriers have limits as to how much benefit they will take over, and will refuse to take the case if those limits are exceeded. Underwriter – is another term for the Insurer, although it is not commonly used. Another definition of Underwriter is an employee who works in the Underwriting department. This department is responsible for assessing whether a risk is a good one, deciding whether an exception can be made on rates, provision of benefits, or liberalizing the rules if the reason for the exception makes sense.
TLR – Target Loss Ratio - Portion of the premium that is used to cover the projected claims, equals 100% - expense level in % of premium.
TPA – Third party administrator – an organization that does billing and administration
TPP – Third party payor – an organization that pays claims. Not an insurance provider.
Trend - Level by which that claims are expected to grow due to price inflation, increase in utilization, introduction of new expensive treatment
TSA - taxable spending account, aka wellness spending account - Just like the healthcare spending account, the TSA is a fund of money provided to employees, paid for by the employer. Just like with the HSA, the employers pays an admin fee to the provider to administer the claims. With the TSA employees can use it for literally anything. Yes anything. Most providers will set a contract with the employer to narrow down anything to most things, divvied up into categories to help drive employee behaviour with a goal of health and wellness in mind. These are commonly used for fitness memberships and sports equipment. It can also be used to buy insurance products like optional insurance, pet insurance and virtual care

Underwriting - The process of assessing risk and determining the required rates for the group.

Vol. AD&D - Voluntary Accidental Death & Dismemberment - the terms “Voluntary” and
“Optional” are interchangeable - usually available to both the employee and the spouse, and
sometimes on the children as well.
Volume of Insurance - the amount of insurance an employee is insured for. If his Life is
$50,000 then the volume is $50,000. This can also be called the “benefit amount”
 
Waiver of Premium - When an employee becomes disabled, his life insurance premium may be waived for the duration of his disability.
WI - Weekly Indemnity or Weekly Income - means exactly the same as STD
Important note about calculation of benefits:
Life Insurance and AD&D are rounded up to the next highest $1,000 if not already an even multiple of $1000.
WI and LTD are rounded up to the next $1.00 if not already an even multiple of $1.
Life, AD&D, WI, and LTD unit rates are usually rounded to 3 decimal places.
Dependent Life, Extended Health, and Dental are 2 decimal places, since all are a “cost per person”.
Tweet
View my profile on LinkedIn

Share

4/12/2022

Will the national dental plan save me money on my employee benefit plan?

Read Now
 
Will the national dental plan save me money on my employee benefit plan?
 
In short – probably not. Not right away anyway. This what we know about the dental plan today.
It will start with those under 12 years old some time in 2022. In 2023 the program will expand to those under 18, seniors and persons living with a disability. By 2025, the program will be fully implemented. The program is income restricted. Families with an income of less than $90,000 will be eligible and only those with an income of less than $70,000 will not pay anything.
​
Let’s break this down. Here’s what we don’t really know yet.

First – a lot of services fall under dental care. Everything from cleaning your teeth, to fillings, to crowns, to braces. What will the government cover? At the point of writing this, we have no idea. I suspect it will be basic coverage.
Second what does fully implemented mean? Does that mean all Canadians making a family income of less than 90,000? The income threshold seems to be aligned with the median family income in Canada, which is $90,390. Will this amount be adjusted annually to keep up with wage changes in inflation?

Third – How will this program interact with insurance plans? Will more details reveal that the program is only for those without insurance? Will the program coordinate with insurance plans? Will the national dental program pay first, before an insurance plan pays or will it let the insurance plan pay first?

You’re probably thinking, but coverage for 12 years old and younger is starting right away. Won’t that save the employee benefit plan money? It will, but probably not a lot. Here’s why.

About 15% of the total population is aged 0-14 years old. That’s a pretty decent amount of the population. But many of those years’ kids don’t see the dentist. Plus (with the exception of braces) the work kids are having done mostly falls into the basic dental category which costs a lot less than crowns, caps, implants and other major work that happens as we age.

Let’s dig into this income cap that limits coverage eligibility. This is what will exclude most people from qualifying for the plan. The national dental program is only for people who have a family income of $90,000 or less. Key word here is family. A family income includes the incomes of everyone in the family which in most cases is the two adults. In 2015 69% of families had both parents working aka dual income.

In Canada the median family income is $90,390. Median is different from average. Median is the middle – it means that half of Canadian families make more than $90,390 and half make less. Using the median income in Canada to qualify for the plan, means half of Canadas will not be allowed to use the national dental care plan. Of the half that are able to use the plan, many will still have to pay to use the coverage. Only those with a family income of less than $70,000 will not have to pay anything for the plan. Again, we don’t know what will be covered in the plan.
What about coordination? How will the new national dentalcare program interact with insurance plans. We don’t know.  With drugs, the system to coordinate with provincial coverage is already set up. For dentalcare a new system will need to be set up for dentists to submit claims to the government plan for reimbursement. Insurance carriers and dental offices will need clarification on the order of payment. In insurance there is something called a first payor. The first payor is the main source of insurance coverage and where the dental office will submit claims first. After the first payor has refunded the dental office for the claim if there is any cost left to pay, and the individual who had the dental services has other coverage that plan may pay for the services. Or if there is no other coverage available then the individual will pay.

No matter what or who the new national dentalcare program covers, employers will save money. But employers should not rush to reduce or remove dental coverage until we know the unknown. With dental costs on the rise, and turnover at an all time high, employers should stay on track with their benefit program updates. Once more is known about the plan, we can make smart decisions on what to change, if anything about the dentalcare portion of the employee benefits plan.
 
*most of the stats in this article are from Stats Canada. The google machine will find them for you if you ask nicely. 
Tweet

Share

4/11/2022

5 reasons why employers should NOT pause benefit plan updates because of national pharmacare and dental care announcements

Read Now
 
​5 reasons why employers should NOT pause benefit plan updates because of national pharmacare and dental care announcements:
 
1.  The dentalcare program won’t be fully launched until 2025 if it keeps to the proposed timeline.
2. The dentalcare program has a household income limit of $90,000. This means most employees will not qualify for the program.
3. Pharmacare wasn’t given money in the 2022 budget and will take a long time to launch anything. We have no idea what this program will and will not cover.
4. Drugs and dental costs are rising now and are not slowing down. If you were planning on making plan changes that will help reduce your drug risk, you should still do those.
5. Employee turnover is at an all time high and will continue for the foreseeable future. Group benefit plan enhancements can help you win and keep employees.  

Let’s dig into employee benefit plan updates a little more.
 
The 2021 Driving Data with Decisions – Benefits Strategy and Benchmarking Survey by Gallagher found that 62% of employers have no plans to update their benefit program. In fact, most benefit plans haven’t had an update to the drug plan in over a decade. Why are employers setting and forgetting something that costs anywhere form 5-15% of payroll?
 
It’s all about change – people hate change and if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. But I would argue that benefits are broken to an extent. Plans we put in place and haven’t updated a decade ago don’t address today’s concerns. Digital, personalized, risk, cost. These have all evolved.
 
Employees want a personalized benefits experience, one that meets their needs (wants) now and in the future as their lives change. Most people, also have a case of the “that won’t happen to me’s” which means employers will need to consider how much they listen to what employees want.
 
To decide what part of the plan to update, and if they should update the plan at all, employers should start by answering this question – what is the purpose of the employee benefit program? Is it a tool to recruit employees? Is it something they just have to offer? Is it a tool to protect employees from expensive life events, like a disability or chronic condonation? Is it a tool to keep employees healthy? From there employers can determine how much they can afford to pay for the plan now and in the future.
 
Once an employer understands what they want to accomplish with their group benefits, they can update the group benefit plan. A few items that all employers should consider as they decide on what updates to make are:

  1. Plan affordability - Can I afford a high-cost drug claim? What about two? If these happen what does this mean for future costs of the plan?
  2. Plan personalization - Can I spend a little more to offer employees choice through spending accounts? The Benefits Canada Healthcare survey shows years over years how much employees love spending counts, but the large majority of employers still don’t offer them despite the low cost. A $300 spending account would only cost an employer around $345 IF the employee actually used the who thing. But most employees won’t.
  3. Relevance - Do I need to update the dental plan? Dental costs are on the rise. This means two things – your dental plan will cost more in the future, and employee’s have less buying power. A $1500 dental maximum doesn’t cover what it once did. I recently had an annual cleaning and including x-rays it cost over $400.
  4. Support - Do my employees have the support they need for their mental health?
  5. Plan communication - Do the employees know what is currently being offered in the plan, what it’s for and how to use the coverage? What about the many free virtual care and mental health options that are available? I share some of them in a list here.
 

Tweet

Share

3/13/2022

Employee Benefits Fraud like a really bad game of Monopoly

Read Now
 
Picture
Employee benefits fraud is the real deal. When someone - an employee or provider commits benefits fraud they are stealing from the employer who offers the group benefit program - NOT the insurance carrier.

The consequences of benefits fraud are like the cards in the game of Monopoly. 

You don't get to pass go and collect your $200 because you're fired. Stealing from your employer is a serious and fire-able offence. This can also make it difficult to find a new job. 

If you're lucky you'll land a get out of jail free card. Even if you do, a fraud conviction results in a permanent criminal record. A permanent record will make doing fun things like travelling difficult. You could also have difficulty getting a job and achieving other life goals like buying a home.

Like the community chest card - you'll still have to pay your doctor's fee. Those who commit fraud could be responsible to repay the stolen money.

Not committing benefits fraud is easy and you can learn more at fraudisfraud.ca

​

Tweet

Share

2/18/2022

Was Baby One More Time playing the last time you updated your benefit plan?

Read Now
 
I read a stat from the Envoy Return to Workplace Report that reveled 63% of employees say flexibility would make them feel more empowered. The 2020 Benefits Canada Healthcare Survey shows how much value plan members place on having some control over how they can use their health benefit plans.

Personalizing benefits is key to unlocking an engaged workforce.  The definition of personalized is “design or produce (something) to meet someone's individual requirements”. Personalizing benefits gives employees the flexibility and control they need.
I participated in a couple of webinars last week that focused on plan member personalization. Below are some the stats that make a compelling argument to giving plan members more flexible benefit options.

  • 87% of plan members who view their benefit plan quality as excellent/very good are also satisfied with their job. Compared to only 50% of plan members who view their benefit plan quality as poor.
  • 68% of those with HSAs say their health benefit plan meets their needs, compared to 49% among those without HSAs.
  • 82% of plan members would like to have a healthcare spending account and those who already have one, love it.

The top 4 products that plan members would like to use if added to their benefit plan can be delivered through a taxable spending account (Fitness Classes, Personal fitness trainer, Virtual Care, Fitness tracking devices).

BUT

The Gallagher Driving Data with Decisions Survey found that 62% of plan sponsors have no plans to make updates to the benefit program. The great reset is on. Headlines are 40% of employees say they are at least somewhat likely to quit in the next three to six months. Mass attrition is happening. It’s widespread, and will persist for the foreseeable future.

Stale, outdated plans from a decade ago, that try to fit everyone into the same tiny box, push great people out the door and open the door to disrupters and to competitors. 
Tweet

Share

2/14/2022

Should Employee Benefit Providers embed “value add” products inside the healthcare rate?

Read Now
 
Should Employee Benefit Providers embed “value add” products inside the healthcare rate?
 
This is kind of a big and loaded question because whether or not  they should, they do. It’s common practice.

I will admit that my opinion has evolved over time. I used to think of products embedded in the healthcare rate as a value add and as insurance carrier differentiator. But not anymore. How can a product add value if it’s not wanted? Then it becomes a takeaway. When employers are not given the option to opt out of these so-called value adds, and when the cost is hidden it becomes problematic. Some quick disclosure, over at my day job, my employer and insurance carrier Equitable Life doesn’t embed costs. But my opinion on this was actually reshaped when I was working on the advisor side of our business. Multiple billing wasn’t as big a deal as I thought it was and the admin liability risk on forgetting to add someone to the wellness program is low. Plus these providers do a great job making set up and ongoing admin a breeze.
 
Way back in 2006 when I joined the wonderful group benefits industry the costs hiding in the healthcare rate were limited to the pooling charge and Best Doctors. Best Doctors is the OG value add. If my memory serves me well, the cost was around $0.50 for a single and $1 family. But today hidden costs have ballooned to include the second opinion program, HR tools, wellness (like lumino and vitality) EAPs, virtual care and more.
 
All of these programs have a cost.
 
So who cares? What’s the big deal?
 
Benefit plans are under pressure. Drug risk is high, disability is suffering from prolonged historically low interest rates coupled with longer duration periods and higher incident rates. Dental fee guides are increase 5-7%. Higher cost is everywhere. These embedded programs could cost an employer anywhere from $1-$5 per person. Since well all like percentages, that could be as high as 10% of the single healthcare rate. Imagine if your clients had an extra 10% to spend?
 
Here's what else an HR department could get for $1 - $5 per person
  1. Scheduling software
  2. HRIS
  3. Employee Recognition Program
  4. Weekly fruit basket
  5. A $50 increase to the HSA or WSA
 
The list goes on.
 
The other problem is that it complicates future cost forecasting. The cost for the add on products is backed out of the healthcare premium in renewal calculations. You can’t quick and dirty math your way into a three-year cost prediction. In addition to backing out the pooling charge you now have to dig into how much do each of these add ons cost. I’m not a fan of this lack of transparency.
 
Instead, why don’t we price each of these options and let employers choose if they would like to offer the program to their employees? Not all employers want these services tied to their insurer. It creates additional change management for employees. New insurer, new EAP, new virtual care, new wellness. It’s too much.
 
What do you think? Should third party services be billed in the health rate? Should they be mandatory or optional?
Tweet

Share

1/7/2022

Resolutions

Read Now
 
Picture
Let's all promise to make meaningful resolutions this year  that we can keep. With that in mind, I give you, group benefit resolutions for the advisor, plan sponsor and plan member!

Plan Advisor
  1. Communicate the solutions already built into my client’s plans that support employee health.
  2. Include the policy number in all email subject lines to the benefits provider.
  3. Stop moving groups for cost, start moving groups for value and service.
Employer / Plan Sponsor
  1. Make sure plan members know what benefits are available, when to use them and how to access the program.
  2. Have a drug risk conversation with your benefit advisor.
  3. Be supportive of employee's health goals.
Employee / Plan Member
  1. Take ownership of my benefits & find out what my employer offers to me.
  2. Download benefit provider app.
  3. Take full advantage of any RRSP or Pension matching.
Bonus, the Insurer: Stop released quotes that knowingly underfund the claims.
 
Tweet

Share

2/28/2021

Podcast Dreams

Read Now
 
In 2017 something exciting happened. GSC Canada launched a podcast. It was the first employee benefits podcast that I listened to and now I can't get enough.  Since then a number of podcasts have launched. Some have come and gone, others evolved and some have thrived. Here is a list of my favourite (alphabetically!) mostly benefits related, some fintech related podcasts.

Have I messed any?! Add them to the comments. You'll find these where you listen to podcasts!
  • And Now for Something Completely Indifferent with GSC Canada
  • BCC CE Drive with Jason watt 
  • Benefits Connexion with Denise Balch 
  • Benefits of Knowledge with Lorne Curry
  • Fintech impact with Jason Pereira 
  • New! admittedly I haven't listed yet, but am looking forward to the first episode. Insuretech Canada podcast with John Harvey 
  • The SPM podcast with Chad Dawson 
  • Starting with one with Robin Bailey
  • HR ShopTalk 

Bonus: US based with relevant general topics like how to make decisions with discernment is Benefits Influencer with Ned Schaut 
​
Tweet

Share

12/6/2020

I Read it, So YOU Don’t Have To the 70 page goodie from HBM+: 2020 Drug Trends and Strategic Insights

Read Now
 
Picture
In this episode of I Read it, so YOU Don’t Have To is the 70 page goodie from HBM+: 2020 Drug Trends and Strategic Insights. You can access this report here. I recommend viewing the many visuals and reading the section on drug formularies: page 44-48.

Ready?! Let’s dive in.

Who is HBM+? One of the largest pharmacy and health benefits managers in Canada, HBM+ is a division of Green Shield Canada.
 
The data presents drug claims and utilization data for their six partner insurers and third party administrators (TPAs), representing over two million claimants, and over $1.5 billion in annual adjudicated drug cost. These are their insights (peppered with my commentary of course).
 
If you have read any drug claim report in the past, you’re familiar with what’s about to come. Drugs costs are rising, high costs drugs are a problem. Etc, etc. So here it is again. Only this time, let’s take action after reading this.
 
Since 2014 drug trend ranges from 4 to 14.2% (taking out the OHIP+ blip year where the Liberal government shifted all drug claims for those under age 25 to the province only to have the Ford government quickly reverse that initiative).

The average drug cost per claimant rose from $61.90 in 2015 to $66.00 in 2019. Not noted here, but in other reports is the dramatic difference between the average provincially. This highlights how well provincial drug programs reduce the cost burden on employers. Atlantic Canada has by far the worst average drug cost per claimant and this is directly related to their lack of provincial drug coverage.

The average annual cost per claimant for the top 5% was $8,306 in 2019, which was more than 21 times that of the other 95% of claimants ($392). The top 5% of claimants had an average of 66 claims in 2019, versus just nine claims for the other 95% of claimants.
 
The top 1 % of claimants have an average annual cost of $24,740 which is 31.4% of the total drug costs. This is where we can get a lot of bang for our buck with biosimilars (and a drug formula plus provincial drug plan alignment). Many of these high cost drugs are not just biologic claims, but originator biologic claims. Call to action: Group Benefit Advisors must begin to have proactive risk conversations with employers around biologic drugs. As we see the provinces delisting many originator drugs, not all carriers are following suit making this the risk conversation with employers vital. When an insurer does not also delist a biologic drug, it puts additional risk and unnecessary claim pressure on employers. BC has already delisted a bunch of originator biologics Most insurers in BC also delisted, but a few held out forcing employers to pay for these expensive drugs when the provincial program should have picked up the cost. More on this in the biosimilar section.
 
Generic drugs have been and continue to be an important source of savings for drug plans. Generic penetration rose to 62.5% in 2019 from 55.3% in 2015. There is room for improvement.  Call to Action: If your plan doesn’t already have a lowest cost alternative or mandatory generic substation built into it, what are you waiting for? Do like to spend more for the same product?

The generic price negotiations between Canadian Pharmaceutical Alliance (pCPA) and the Canadian Generic Pharmaceutical Association were key. For some generic molecules, the price was reduced to as little as 10% of the brand-name equivalent
 
They say a picture is worth a 1000 words. I think this graph speaks for itself. While the top drug category is concerning and cannot be ignored, there’s a lot we can do to reduce claims with a healthy lifestyle in other categories.

The average cost per claimant for diabetes is $981 and there are 119,168 claimants. While hypertension has almost 350,000 claimants with a cost of $197 per claimant. We can make significant improvement to claim costs if we proactively tackle these conditions.  Call to Action: what proactive plan design is in place to promote health? What wellness initiatives are built into the employee’s experience?

In 2019 18,200 claimants used a specialty drug. This represents growth of 11.2% over 2018. This is not sustainable and represents a huge risk to benefit plans. The arrival of biosimilars offers incredible opportunities for savings while maintaining plan member access to effective drug therapy.
 
Another cost management strategy that has been successfully employed to manage specialty drug expenditures is preferred pharmacy networks (PPNs). PPNs are an important tool to manage the pharmacy markup of specialty drug claims. As specialty drugs can cost over $100,000 per year, the pharmacy markup represents a substantial sum of money. PPNs are structured to not only reduce the standard pharmacy markup for these claims but also bundle additional value-added services such as adherence support and case management. When combined, these programs can control claim costs and ensure patients are appropriately using these high-cost therapies.
 
Pharmacy Listing agreements are equally essential in the management of specialty claims. Since 2010, the pan-Canadian Pharmaceutical Alliance (pCPA), has utilized the collective buying power of the provincial drug plans (and the federal government) to negotiate drug prices for over 200 drugs. As of March 2019, the pCPA has been able to realize savings of over $2.26 billion annually. This effort has substantially enhanced the sustainability of public drug plans across the country. No such collective buying effort currently exists in the private sector. Shifting the cost of a high cost claim from the employer, to the public pan whenever possible is a key strategy for employer drug plans.
 
Since 2014, 10 biosimilar products impacting private drug plans have been approved and marketed in Canada to treat a range of different conditions, including diabetes, Crohn’s disease, psoriasis, and neutropenia. Biosimilars present comparable safety and efficacy to their originator products, but at a significantly lower cost; in fact, the discount attributable to a biosimilar relative to a reference product is
over 50% for some products.

As private drug plans embrace biosimilar-first policies and biosimilar transitioning, biosimilar penetration is expected to grow substantially in the coming years. The benefits of these therapies for private drug plans extend beyond immediate cost savings, translating into better integration with public plans, many of which are starting to implement biosimilar switching policies. In particular, in 2019, British Columbia became the first Canadian province to implement a biosimilar transitioning program for all Residents that led to substantial savings for the public drug plan without compromising patient safety or access to drug therapy. Since then, Alberta has also announced the implementation of a biosimilar switching policy, and it is expected that Ontario will make policy decisions to move forward with a similar approach. Call to action: talk to employers about the risk of being insured by a carrier who has not also delisted these drugs.
 
 Most chronic disease sufferers claim for maintenance drugs on an ongoing basis, after initial effectiveness is established. It follows that maintenance drugs should be dispensed at three-month intervals to facilitate patient adherence and reduce overall dispensing fee costs.
 
In 2015, 90-day supply claims made up close to 28% of the total number of claims As a result of the implementation of the maintenance medication dispensing frequency policy in 2016, the share of 90-day supply claims rose steadily over time before stabilizing at around 40% in 2019. In that same time, claims for 30-day supply dropped from 19.9% of the total number of claims, to only 10.5%
 
Opioid management is an important topic since there is an epidemic of opioid overdoses. HMB+ notes that the issue is extremely completed and cannot be solved by one stakeholder alone. It will require a concerted effort among multiple partners, including health care providers, insurers, TPAs, advisors, plan sponsors, and pharmacy benefit managers. They go on to describe their three-component opioid
management policy: focus on abuse deterrence, restrictions on long-acting formulations, and opioid medication utilization reviews. Implementation of this policy instantly lowered the number of claimants using oxycodone from about 160 in May 2017 to just 10 claimants in July. The drop in the number of claimants eventually stabilized at an average of just 17 claimants monthly in 2019.
 
Managed formularies are one of the most effective, yet underutilized tools to drive value and cost containment. Managed formularies are based on the premise that drug prices are not always commensurate with the level of therapeutic value they deliver. This is supported by analysis undertaken by the Patented Medicines Price Review Board (PMPRB). Based on a 2017 report from the PMPRB, 82% of new drugs that entered the Canadian market between 2010 and 2017 were classified as offering little to no improvement over existing therapies, and only 5% were classified as breakthrough or had a substantial improvement over existing therapies.
 
With this understanding, managed formularies are designed to bend the curve on drug spending by proactively encouraging the use of the most cost-effective treatments that generate value for both plan sponsors and plan member
 
Under an open formulary, non-high-cost drugs approved by Health Canada are covered regardless of their cost or whether or not they provide any meaningful value over existing therapies. In 2019 79% of claimants belonged to a plan with an open formulary.
 
The lack of adoption can be attributed to many reasons. One reason being the advisor community has not bought into the need for formularies. Even as drug costs skyrocket, group benefit advisors fail to successfully implement the most fundamental tool for cost containment. Call to action – learn more about what formularies insurers offer and how these can help employers save.
 
Another reason is managing change. No one likes to change. Change is work for the benefits advisor, the plan sponsor, and the employees. Strong, effective communication is a must.
The report notes the perception by plan sponsors that managed formularies severely restrict access to new and existing drugs. Many of those concerns are unfounded as the majority of drugs remain available as a general benefit and only a small subset are, in fact, a non-benefit.
 
Ultimately adopting a managed formulary ensures better management of a small subset of drugs that are costlier than existing therapies but may not offer additional value, while still maintaining open access to the vast majority of drugs on the market
 
Still need proof? Canadian guidelines recommend metformin (cost $.20/day) as the initial agent of choice for newly diagnosed type 2 diabetes patients. Open formulary plan designs render factors like affordability irrelevant because they make all agents available at any point in the treatment journey without regard to cost-effectiveness. That is, a newly diagnosed patient could bypass metformin and/or sulfonylureas ($0.15/day) and start treatment with a costlier SGLT-2 inhibitor or a GLP-1 agonist ($2.70/day to $7.88/day) in the absence of valid clinical rationale for doing so.
 
Emerging and future trends notes are Pharmacogenomics, Value Based Pharmacy (VBP), and Gene Therapy
Pharmacogenomics: Pharmacogenomics is an exciting new field that has the potential to transform the way many common medications are prescribed. A form of personalized medicine, pharmacogenomics is based on the principle that certain genetic mutations have been shown to influence the metabolism of drugs. The goal of pharmacogenomics is to predict patient response to medications, including the potential to avoid negative side-effects. Based on pharmacogenomic information, a physician or pharmacist can initiate or modify medications that are best suited for a particular individual.
 
The HMB+ study showed that patients whose medication treatment is optimized and guided by the results of their pharmacogenomic test can achieve better outcomes compared with patients whose treatment relies purely on clinical (i.e., pharmacist and physician) judgment. It lends support for the inclusion of pharmacogenomics in benefit plans for specific clinical scenarios to optimize patient health outcomes.
 
That sounds great – sign me up! Not so fast. Health data is some of the most valuable and thus susceptible to cyberattacks. One must ensure that health data is sufficiently protected. Another issue is privacy. Earlier this year the Supreme Court of Canada upheld the genetic non-discrimination law which ensures Canadians can take genetic tests without being disadvantaged for insurance. But what if that changes?

VBP: an important, though often overlooked determinant of success are the health care professionals themselves, specifically pharmacists. As medication therapy experts, pharmacists play an essential role in ensuring that patients’ drug therapies are safe and effective, managing patient adherence, and improving health outcomes. HBM+ implemented a VBP Program in 2018. Through the VBP Program, pharmacies in Canada (except Quebec) that submit claims to HBM+ are evaluated for the quality of care that they deliver to patients based on eight validated, evidence-based, quality-of-care measures.
 
Gene Therapy can be considered a new paradigm in drug development that will yield hundreds of new treatments in the coming years. In fact, within the next two years, the number of approved gene therapies worldwide is expected to double. The majority of these are in the oncology space with two-thirds of active clinical trials in 2019 looking at leukemia, lymphoma, and solid tumors, but there are notable developments in treatments for cardiovascular disease, endocrine and metabolic disease, blood disorders, and ophthalmology.
 
End.

Tweet
View my profile on LinkedIn

Share

8/17/2020

GUEST POST! What benefits are you missing out on?

Read Now
 
The GAB is excited to share our first guest post. What benefits are you missing out on? From limited access due to COVID to never having used some services, our guest author Kristy Papas dives into her experience exploring with the benefits program.  And not, I'm not talking about the fee coffee and tea! Although I do miss the office fruit basket.

Our body and our mind both need TLC and I am not talking about the chasing waterfalls kind. We need to take the time and opportunity to check in with ourselves. Like cars, we must have regular maintenance check ups. With this in mind, I wonder how many people realize the tools available to support this important, but often neglected, component of our lives. Putting aside the stigmas or your other priorities, there is a lot of support out there for our mental health and general wellbeing.
 
Stop and think when did you last take the opportunity to look at what benefits your employer offers you in the way of paramedical resources or wellness spending opportunities. By paramedical, I am referring to psychologists, counsellors, registered massage therapists (RMT), physiotherapy, acupuncturists and more. By wellness spending opportunities, I mean purchasing ski passes, gym memberships, at home fitness equipment. The potential list goes on and on and on. I encourage you to stop and investigate what options are at your fingertips. Options that make important resources more affordable or accessible to you.
 
I don’t think we should overuse our benefits as that inevitably increases premium costs for the collective whole. However, if there is a genuine need or even a general curiosity to improve your overall health and wellbeing then I encourage you to get in tune with your body and mind and identify the key areas you want to give some attention to. I know for myself two areas I really benefited from were therapy sessions for my mind and RMT sessions for my body.
 
We spend a lot of time grinding away in a non-ergonomic work environment or perhaps not stretching before and after a workout so having someone work on any pain points or tension can be incredibly beneficial. There are also some of us that spend a lot of time internally wrestling with some important issues and struggles. Having a professionally trained, unbiased person to confide in is therapeutic. It allows us to lean into our thoughts and our feelings and hopefully gives us the capacity to outgrow them or take back the power they wield over us.
 
No matter what you want to work on for yourself, internally or externally, I invite you to find some minutes sooner rather than later to look at what choices are available to you. Reach out to your Human Resources department or Benefits provider for more information. Your body, mind and soul, and perhaps even those around you, will be thankful for this small effort that you put in to prioritizing you. I promise you will not regret it!

About our guest author: Kristy Papas is an digital content creator focusing on stop motion animation, photography, and recipe development. In a past life Kristy did your payroll! If you want you follow Kristy's work, or work with her, you can find her on Instagram, connect with Kristy on LinkedIn or through her website.



Share

<<Previous
Forward>>
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • About GAB
  • Group Benefits Blog
  • The Friday GAB
  • Contact